South Asians for Human Rights

Promoting Democracy, Upholding Human Rights

LONDON: Pakistan remained among the top five executioners of the world, like 2015, despite carrying out 239 less executions in 2016 from the previous year, reported Amnesty International on Tuesday.

“At least four of those executed included prisoners convicted by the military courts established in January 2015 to try civilians suspected of terrorism-related offences for a period of two years. At least 133 people were sentenced to death by these courts during the year,” the report states.

The drop in executions in Pakistan impacted the overall figures of Asia Pacific. “At least 130 executions were carried out in 2016 in 11 countries, down from at least 367 executions in 12 countries in 2015. This was mainly due to Pakistan, where executions decreased by 239 [73 per cent]”.

Furthermore, death sentences observed a significant increase. “Figures from the NGO Human Rights Commission of Pakistan indicated that a further 277 death sentences were imposed by civilian courts during the year, including 193 by ordinary courts and 31 by Anti-Terrorism Courts – special courts established under the Anti-Terrorism Act of 1997 – which the authorities have used to try defendants charged with offences under the Penal Code.”

According to report, China executed more people in 2016 than all other nations combined.

The human rights organisation estimates the Asian giant alone killed “thousands” of people, a figure based on examinations of court records and news reports.

All other countries together executed at least 1,032 people last year — a decline of 37 percent compared to 2015. Of those, 87 percent took place in just four countries – Iran, Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Pakistan.

Amnesty’s report found that hundreds of death sentences, including cases involving foreign nationals, had been omitted from China’s public database of court verdicts, suggesting a concerted effort to hide the extent of the country’s killings.

The ruling Communist Party considers the death toll a state secret.

“China is really the only country that has such a complete regime of secrecy over executions,” Amnesty’s East Asia director Nicholas Bequelin said at a press conference in Hong Kong.

“Probably the reason is the numbers are shockingly high, and China doesn’t want to be a complete outlier in the world,” he said.

Despite local media reports saying at least 931 individuals were executed between 2014 and 2016, only 85 of them were in the online database, Amnesty said.

In 2013, China’s Supreme People’s Court ruled that legal judgements should be made public, but the decision included many exceptions, including cases involving “state secrets” or personal privacy.

Previous estimates from other rights groups also put the number of annual executions in China in the thousands.

Chinese courts have a conviction rate of 99.92 percent, and concerns over wrongful verdicts are fuelled by police reliance on forced confessions and the lack of effective defence in criminal trials.

The nation’s top judge, Zhou Qiang, apologised in 2015 for past miscarriages of justice and said mistakes must be corrected.

In December 2016, a Chinese court cleared a man executed 21 years ago for murder, citing insufficient evidence in the original trial.

However experts say recent reforms have not been widely implemented.

“For example, coerced confessions are supposed to be excluded from evidence. In practise, however, the police have unchallenged discretion to…extract confessions by detaining and torturing suspects for long periods,” New York University professor Jerome Cohen told AFP.

“Yet even the late Communist Party Chairman Mao Zedong, perhaps the greatest executioner in human history, recognised the likelihood of mistakes when imposing the death penalty,” Cohen noted.

“Mao admonished his officials to bear in mind that, once someone’s head is cut off, it cannot grow back.”

A 2016 report from the US-based Dui Hua Foundation said China’s average death row prisoner waits only two months for execution.

Only a handful of countries still use the death penalty with regularity.

The United States executed 20 last year, the lowest figure for the country since 1991.


Updated: 12.04.2017